Well, there's a twist (yep, the Scoobies and especially Anya are great at finding loopholes). *Can* Anariel choose Maia? Did Lùthien do so, and was that her final choice? And what did Morgoth leave on Anariel's neck?

... I'm enjoying this a lot; you don't have to answer any of my questions; I just suck at delayed gratification.